We live in a world full of spoilers. Haven’t watched the latest episode of the most popular T.V. show? You better steer clear of social media. Haven’t seen the latest Star Wars movie? You might as well lock yourself in your house because the spoilers are waiting for you!

So what about Broadway musicals? Do the same “no spoilers” rules apply here? Most people have access to the cast album before they even see a show. So the question becomes, do you listen to the cast album before you see it?

We asked the Hollywood Pantages staff to take a quick poll. It became pretty clear to us that people are very passionate about this issue. We’ve broken down their arguments into a for and against list. Where do you stand?